Birnbeck plans compared to Alcatraz

10:00 11 November 2013

Birnbeck Presentation

Birnbeck Presentation


PROPOSED villas on Birnbeck Island have been described as an ‘eyesore’ and likened to Alcatraz prison.

Wahid Samady exclusively revealed his vision to resurrect Birnbeck Pier in last week’s Mercury, with 15-20 villas on the island and about 170 flats jutting out from the mainland.

However his plans have been heavily criticised by his former business partner, a councillor and the majority of Mercury readers.

Mr Samady said the scale of development is necessary to generate £10million profit which would pay for the pier’s repair and his design would help put the town back on the map.

Cllr John Crockford-Hawley was shown the plans months ago by Mr Samady but he had to promise not to reveal them to the public in return.

He said: “For more than two decades we’ve seen one ridiculous scheme follow another.

“While any successful business at the pier will be dependent upon income generation I’m afraid this Samady plan would create an eyesore of such enormity that the historic pier itself would sink into architectural oblivion.”

Jim Scott, Mr Samady’s former business partner and joint-owner of the former Royal Pier Hotel, was equally critical.

He said: “The island development seems to have been draw up by the same architect who designed Alcatraz.

“Maybe it could be used as a prison when nobody buys what will be overpriced luxury apartments in the middle of the murky Bristol Channel and the three fingers on stilts idea seems to have been cobbled together to resemble a Vietnamese fishing village.”

An online poll run on the Mercury website showed 47 per cent of readers were in favour of Mr Samady’s proposal. But comments left online and posted on the Mercury’s Facebook page were almost unanimously critical.

Messages described Mr Samady’s vision as ‘pie in the sky’, ‘disgusting’ and a ‘monstrosity’.

Concerns over whether there would be enough parking - despite Mr Samady saying the bottom floor of each block of flats would have room for vehicles - and accessibility for emergency vehicles were also raised.

Cllr Crockford-Hawley added: “There is only one way forward and that is for the pier to pass into charitable hands with substantial Heritage Lottery Fund involvement.

“The alternative lies in the muddy depths below.”


  • The plans show some car parking space on the landside. But don't show the access to the parking levels. Will it be by car lifts ? Mega expensive, and what if the lift breaks down. Or will it be by spiral car ramps ? This would take up a lot of space, plus all the space required to park say, 170 cars, in the three jutting out buildings. That's say, 55 cars each block, plus the space to manoeuvre around amongst the parked cars. Then, there's the 15 to 20 villas on the Island. Where are they going to park ? The Grand Pier has a two ton weight limit on it's Pier. When it caught fire, the fire engines (8 to 10 tons) all had to park on the road (it's the wooden planks that can't take all that weight on such a small tyre footprint). Even if the Birnbeck Pier was built as strong as the Grand Pier, there are many cars and especially 4x4s that weigh 2 tons or more. How would you fancy parking your car landside, and walking 300 yards across the Pier in tonight's drizzle and murk, to your luxury villa ? Sorry, Mr Samady might obtain planning permission, but his plans will never come to fruition.

    Report this comment


    Monday, November 11, 2013

  • Snappy comeback :-) - not too sure I'd want to live there; after the initial attraction had worn off, the island isolation effect would kick-in - depressing after a while, except for, maybe, 2 months in the year? Better it's USP is all year round attractions, TBD?

    Report this comment


    Monday, November 11, 2013

  • Who owns the shore line for the 3 blocks of flats?

    Report this comment


    Monday, November 11, 2013

  • Censored again, can Archant publish those words that is regards as libellous - beats me why my submission was sent into cyberspace, never to be seen again?

    Report this comment


    Monday, November 11, 2013

  • Maybe the place to relocate our more troublesome residents ?

    Report this comment

    Chris White

    Monday, November 11, 2013

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Other News Stories

Yesterday, 19:00
Bra Bank at Beauty By Emma

A WESTON-SUPER-MARE woman has come up with a novel way to support a breast cancer charity.

Read more
Yesterday, 17:30
Comedian Justin Lee Collins at Birnbeck.

A CAMPAIGN to restore Birnbeck Pier has gained support from a celebrity fan.

Read more
Yesterday, 17:00
Counselling is being offered in primary schools.

A GRANT of £10,000 has been given to a Weston-super-Mare school to enable it to provide a counselling programme.

Read more
Yesterday, 15:00
An art exhibition is being held in Cheddar.

ARTISTS will be showing off their work during a festival in Cheddar this weekend.

Read more
Yesterday, 14:47
The lorry fire on the M5 between Burnham-on-Sea and Weston-super-Mare. Photo by Lester Solway.

A stretch of the M5 has been partially closed northbound due to a lorry fire this afternoon (Thursday).

Read more
Yesterday, 13:30
Margaret Hook and staff at Banwell pharmacy.

A VILLAGE pharmacy has won an award for its innovative approach to identifying dementia.

Read more
Yesterday, 13:00
Photo by Terry Kelly.

MORE than 200 people have submitted entries to the Weston At Its Finest calendar competition, which closed this week.

Read more
Yesterday, 12:00
Nick Gargan.

THE next stage of the process to require Avon and Somerset Constabulary’s suspended Chief Constable Nick Gargan to resign has begun.

Read more
Yesterday, 11:00
Stomach of pregnant woman

NORTH Somerset’s watchdog for patients is coming to Weston-super-Mare to find out what the public think of health and social care services.

Read more
Yesterday, 10:07
Mystery witch with green skin holds Halloween pumpkin with gray rat at midnight

WANTED: a full-time witch and wizard.

Read more


All the latest news on Dismaland and Banksy here

Most Read News

Read Online

Read the Weston Worle and Somerset Mercury e-edition E-edition

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 14°C

min temp: 10°C

Great British Life

Great British Life

Useful Links

Advertise in the paper
Submit a Story
Subscribe to the paper
Send Your Letters
Order Photos
Family notices
Reader Travel

Family Notices 24

Search for a job in Weston

Local business directory

Somerset's trusted business finder

Find planning applications