Do college performance tables show a ‘narrow view’ of pupils’ performance?

PUBLISHED: 07:00 06 February 2017

The Department for Education release the 16-18 performance tables. Picture credit: © Royalty-Free/Corbis

The Department for Education release the 16-18 performance tables. Picture credit: © Royalty-Free/Corbis

© Corbis. All Rights Reserved.

North Somerset headteachers have criticised the Department for Education’s 16-18 performance tables for presenting colleges as ‘exam factories’.

Colleges are now rated on progress scores, which rate how much improvement students have made between their GCSEs and A-levels.

Under this system, zero means a college is ‘average’. Anything above zero is better than average, and anything beneath that mark is considered below average.

Traditional core subjects, such as English, maths and science, are given more weight than vocational subjects.

At Weston College, where just one per cent of students study purely the core subjects, the tables suggest students are making less progress than in other places.

However, North Somerset’s headteachers say the ranking methods fails to reflect students’ achievements.

Sidcot School headteacher Iain Kilpatrick said it offers a ‘narrow view’ of a school’s performance, while Weston College principal Dr Paul Phillips said: “The 16-18 performance tables do not understandably lend themselves to further education colleges where students often mix an A-level with a vocational subject.

“We can see the tables probably do serve a purpose for schools but for us it is the level of achievement, the level of progress and the subsequent progression to higher education and employment that make our role worthwhile in producing well-rounded individuals.”

Mr Kilpatrick said his school encourages personal development in students.

He added: “We are not an exam factory, hothousing children to perform through pressure and rote learning.”

More from Weston Mercury


Weston boss Marc McGregor has hailed the performance Tom Llewellyn in the Seagulls’ defeat at Welling United, after the teenage starlet marked his first league start with a stunning goal.

Read more
32 minutes ago

Pupils turned out in droves, sporting yellow ears and eye patches, in support of Children in Need.

Read more

A Weston boy, who has been long been hailed as an inspiration to children suffering from bullying, has added another prestigious prize to his collection.

Read more

Children as young as 12 have been caught running on the roof of a derelict factory and trespassing in the collapsing building.

Read more

A six-year-old has raised more than £500 for a Wraxall charity with a sponsored hair cut.

Read more

The following cases were heard at North Somerset Courthouse from October 4-16.

Read more
In The Dock

The Government is set to invest more than £1million to improve pothole problems in Weston and North Somerset.

Read more
Yesterday, 20:00

Pantomime season will return to Weston-super-Mare next month.

Read more
Yesterday, 18:00

A six-piece jazz band will entertain a Portishead crowd on November 30.

Read more
Yesterday, 17:41

Westonians have criticised North Somerset Council’s commercial investment decisions after the authority spent more than £50million on acquisitions this year.

Read more

Most Read News

Read Online

Read the Weston Worle and Somerset Mercury e-edition E-edition

Local Weather

Sunshine and Showers

Sunshine and Showers

max temp: 6°C

min temp: 2°C

Useful Links

Advertise in the paper
Submit a Story
Subscribe to the paper
Send Your Letters
Order Photos
Family notices
Reader Travel

Family Notices 24

Newsletter Sign Up

Weston Mercury twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Show Job Lists