Fire service probe ‘a stitch-up’, claims suspended chief

PUBLISHED: 18:26 03 August 2017

Avon Fire & Rescue Service needs new leadership, according to a Home Office-commissioned inspector.

Avon Fire & Rescue Service needs new leadership, according to a Home Office-commissioned inspector.

Archant

Fire service probe ‘a stitch-up’, claims suspended chief

The head of Avon Fire Authority, who was suspended last week in the wake of a daming probe into the service’s ‘failings in leadership and culture’, has branded the report a ‘stitch-up’.

Chief Fire Officer Kevin Pearson and his deputy Lorraine Houghton were both suspended following the release of a report calling for a radical shake-up of the service’s leadership.

The report, which was commissioned by the Home Office amid allegations of bullying and management infighting, was written by consultant Dr Craig Baker and revealed concerns about the way the service was run, including payment irregularities.

It said ‘serious concerns remain’ and added ‘it is clear that the leadership arrangements at the authority have not been working effectively for many years’.

However, Mr Pearson, while ‘not well enough to be interviewed’, has come back fighting, branding the exercise a ‘witch hunt’ and challenging Dr Baker’s credibility as an independent and qualified assessor.

In a statement released on Thursday, Mr Pearson labelled the inspection ‘a complete sham’, adding he believed the real agenda was to hand fire service leadership to other authorities.

He said: “That witch hunt has now developed into a full-blown stitch-up. This inspection has been no more than a cynical ploy to discredit the governance, leadership and management of a fire authority in pursuit of a political agenda which seeks to transfer governance to Police and Crime Commissioners.

“The report is biased and imbalanced. It is littered with inaccuracies and misrepresentations.

“The inspection itself was significantly flawed. In a four-month-long investigation, I, as the Chief Fire Officer, was interviewed once.

“The subjects of criticism have never seen the evidence gathered. They have been given no opportunity to test, challenge or substantiate that evidence.

“This is a highly unusual approach to any investigation; it is grossly unfair that people have been made the subjects of criticism on this basis.

“I do not believe the inspectors have the authority, credibility or independence to have reached the conclusions in this report.”

More from Weston Mercury

The sound of music will fill Weston this weekend with some magnificent performers taking to the town’s stages stage.

Read more

A ‘nationally important’ original work by a Weston-super-Mare artist will go on display in the town for the first – and possibly only – time in its history.

Read more

A folk favourite will perform in Somerset next month.

Read more
19:00

A Weston-super-Mare carer had her hair shaved off last week in memory of a former colleague and friend.

Read more

People living in Burnham and Highbridge have decided to adopt a neighbourhood plan, which sets out guidelines for developers submitting planning applications in the area.

Read more

Volunteer marshals are needed to help support Weston-super-Mare’s Carnival.

Read more

Weston will be full of amazing tastes and flavours again this weekend as a food festival returns to town.

Read more

One of the nation’s biggest boy bands will celebrate 30 years of music making with a landmark UK tour.

Read more

Hornets nearly overcame a 27-point deficit against Thornbury, but in the end finished two points short.

Read more

Winscombe Ladies put in an outstanding display against Totnes, despite slipping to defeat.

Read more

Most Read News

Read Online

Image
Read the Weston Worle and Somerset Mercury e-edition E-edition

Local Weather

Thunderstorms

Thunderstorms

max temp: 15°C

min temp: 11°C

Useful Links

Advertise in the paper
Submit a Story
Subscribe to the paper
Competitions
Send Your Letters
Order Photos
Family notices
iwitness24
Facebook
Twitter
Reader Travel

Family Notices 24

Newsletter Sign Up

Weston Mercury twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Show Job Lists