‘Councillors failing to scrutinise policy-makers’

PUBLISHED: 08:00 15 August 2018

Congresbury Residents' Action Group (CRAG).

Congresbury Residents' Action Group (CRAG).

Archant

Councillors responsible for scrutinising major housing plans have been accused of ‘dereliction of duty’ by villagers.

North Somerset Council’s strategic planning and economic development policy and scrutiny panel (SPED), has come under 
fire from the North Somerset Village’s Alliance (NSVA) – which has levelled claims that the committee ‘does not know what it is doing’.

The NSVA – an action group bidding to prevent large housing development in North Somerset’s countryside – believes SPED is falling short of its requirement to keep the council’s executive committee in check.

The criticism centres on proposals to build tens of thousands of homes across North Somerset in the next two decades, known as the Joint Spatial Plan (JSP), with ‘garden villages’ created on the edges of Banwell and Churchill.

NSVA secretary Viv Tomkinson has accused SPED of applying ‘no scrutiny’ to JSP decisions at meetings, but SPED chairman Charles Cave has rebutted NSVA’s claims, arguing members examine policy ‘robustly’.

An NSVA spokesman said: “Delegates were amazed members of the SPED did not appear to know what they were doing.

“The criticism follows a recent meeting of SPED at which members did not seem to realise their function was to hold the executive to account.”

NSVA co-chairman Mary Short, who is also chairman of Congresbury Residents’ Action Group, added: “We have looked at the council’s constitution and that is precisely their job.

“The clue is in the committee’s title – scrutiny – I don’t know what else they think is their reason for existence if not to scrutinise the executive.”

But Cllr Cave believes SPED is effective at keeping tabs on policy and the executive members’ actions.

He told the Mercury: “All panel members are aware of their responsibilities.

“The panel’s February meeting made a robust public statement to the executive expressing serious concerns regarding the JSP.

“Now the JSP has been submitted, the panel is focusing on the local plan.

“Within this process the panel is both critical of, and seeks to constructively influence and shape, the plan’s outcome.

“Best results are not always achieved by just confrontation.”

More from Weston Mercury

18:02

The first round proper of the FA Cup awaits Weston-super-Mare after beating Bath City 1-0 in a pulsating tie this afternoon (Saturday).

Read more
15:00

Don’t miss our weekly round-up of readers’ pictures and share yours with the Mercury at: www.iwitness24.co.uk

Read more
iwitness24

Weston’s X Factor hopeful has said she ‘would not change a thing’ after failing to progress to the next round.

Read more
14:53

Events were held in Weston to mark World Mental Health Day.

Read more
12:00

Social media users are unhappy plans to expand The Mall shopping centre at Bristol’s Cribbs Causeway have been torn up, despite claims from political chiefs the decision is good for Weston-super-Mare’s businesses.

Read more

The iconic songs of America’s most commercially successful rock band will be recreated in Weston-super-Mare next month, and Mercury readers could win tickets to the show.

Read more
08:02

More people are dying in care homes instead of in hospital.

Read more
07:40

A preschool will shut in Yatton at the end of the month as a lack of funding means it can no longer afford to go on.

Read more
Yatton
Yesterday, 21:00

The familiar roar of motorbikes will be heard for miles around in Weston this weekend as the beach race returns.

Read more
Yesterday, 20:45

Live music, puppetry and a captivating fairytale world awaits this month.

Read more
Clevedon

Most Read News

Read Online

Image
Read the Weston Worle and Somerset Mercury e-edition E-edition

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 16°C

min temp: 7°C

Useful Links

Advertise in the paper
Submit a Story
Subscribe to the paper
Competitions
Send Your Letters
Order Photos
Family notices
iwitness24
Facebook
Twitter
Reader Travel

Family Notices 24

Newsletter Sign Up

Weston Mercury twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Show Job Lists